In the midst of the political debate about reforming the health care system in 2009 and 2010, a number of unfortunate myths were spread about what this reform would actually mean to individuals and their families. Since the bill was actually passed in March 2010, it’s important for people to get a real sense of what it means and what’s going to happen, so that they can prepare themselves for the changes that will occur over the next several years.
Myth: There will be ‘death panels’ deciding who deserves care and who instead be subjected to euthanasia.
Fact: This was never in the bill, and was never intended to be added to the bill. At one point there was a provision designed to compensate doctors for time spent discussing end-of-life care with those patients who wished to have the discussion. In fact, these kinds of discussions between a patient and their doctor are designed to make the patient’s wishes clear when it comes to whether they’ll be put on a ventilator or given a feeding tube. The hope is that people who are nearing the end of their lives will have the security of knowing that their wishes will be respected, no matter what their wishes are. This provision ultimately had to be removed from the bill to avoid the political arguments about ‘death panels’.
Myth: Health care is being nationalized.
Fact: While the possibility of a single-payer system was in discussion for some time, it was rejected early in the process. Instead, the bill maintains the current system of health insurance and adds as an option state-run health insurance exchanges through which individuals and small businesses will be able to purchase health insurance coverage.
Myth: Any government involvement with health care will automatically make it into a disaster.
Fact: The government has been running Medicaid and Medicare, along with care through the Veteran’s Administration, for years, and many of the same people arguing that the government’s involvement with health care would be disastrous were claiming that one of their reasons for this was the desire to protect Medicare. The people who receive health care through these programs actually have higher than average levels of satisfaction with their coverage.
Myth: Doctors will have their wages dictated to them by the government.
Fact: Currently, doctors practice privately and then decide what they bill to whoever the patient has coverage through. Often, the company then negotiates with the doctor or dictates what they’ll be willing to pay for the services. This will work the same way under the new system.
Myth: You can’t keep your private insurance.
Fact: There is nothing in the health care reform bill that would take away your private insurance. They’re only adding additional options to make sure that health care will be available, affordable, and actually purchased by a larger portion of the population. At one time they did consider the possibility of moving to a single-payer system, but this idea was dropped early in the process.
Myth: The bill cuts Medicare coverage
Fact: This is one is true, partially. While the money going into Medicare is projected to be cut, the target of the cuts is in the area of making the system more efficient. Also, people who fall into the Medicare coverage gap (often referred to as the ‘doughnut hole’) are going to begin receiving tax rebates to help them deal with the otherwise uncovered expenses. In general, Medicare’s financial situation is projected to improve under the recent health care reform.
Myth: There’ll be no choices for the kind of coverage you want.
Fact: You’ll still get to choose your coverage as you do today. If you work for an employer who offers health care benefits, you’ll pick among the plans that they offer to you (or if you don’t like those plans, you can look elsewhere). If you don’t receive health care coverage, you’ll have the option to buy it through the state-run exchanges and you’ll get to choose which of the plans on the exchange you purchase.
Myth: Health care reform is socialized medicine.
Fact: Creating a socialized system of medicine was never the intention of the reform bill, and isn’t one of the things the bill will do. While the reform does take steps to make coverage available to more people who can’t afford it, similar myths that this amounted to socialized medicine were spread during the debate over the creation of the Medicare system (and notably, even the people complaining about the evils of ‘socialized medicine’ have generally not been calling for the complete dismantling of Medicare).
Myth: You’ll pay higher taxes to cover health care reform.
Fact: The only people who are projected to pay higher taxes are those in the highest tax brackets (above $200,000 for individuals, and $250,000 for married couples filing jointly). Eventually, those receiving very expensive health care plans from their employers will also be taxed on that benefit. The vast majority of the country will not be paying any additional taxes.
Myth: Health care reform will cause health care to be rationed.
Fact: It’s already the case that health care is effectively being rationed. Only the extreme minority of the country can currently afford to directly pay for any health care they could possibly need without having to deal with whether their insurance company will give permission for a procedure or trying a particular drug. Many people currently avoid seeking care at all because they have no insurance and can’t pay for the care they need directly. In addition, when people try to use their insurance coverage they’re always in fear that the company will refuse to cover them, or come up with an excuse to cancel their policy entirely. The purpose of the health care reform bill is to address these injustices, and improve the availability of health care to everyone.
The political fight over health care reform may have confused many people about what the final bill would actually do, but now that the smoke is beginning to clear the real information is coming to light. You should do your best to familiarize yourself with the schedule for the parts of the bill to go into effect and exactly what they’ll do so that you’ll have every possible opportunity to make the decisions about health care and your finances that will best serve the well-being of yourself and your family.



